502 Stream ended unexpectedly repeatedly when context is image-heavy (~23 MB request payload) #997

Summary

In a long session that accumulates many image tool-results, requests start failing with HTTP 502 mid-stream. Typing continue does not recover the turn — the identical retry fails again — until an automatic compaction reduces the context. The failures correlate strongly with request payload size: in the failing request, 90% of the payload was base64 image data (~21 MB of ~23 MB). The session became unusable for ~12 minutes until auto-compaction fired.

Expected Behavior

Either:

• the request succeeds, or
• the client surfaces a clear, actionable error when the payload exceeds the gateway limit (e.g. 413 Payload Too Large with a hint to run /compact),

instead of a mid-stream 502 that looks like a server outage and cannot be recovered by retrying.

Actual Behavior

Error: 502 Stream ended unexpectedly before completion (no finish event) — response was truncated

Type "continue" to try again. If the issue persists, contact support: https://commandcode.ai/discord
Trace ID: <id>

Occurred 3 times in one session:

Payload composition at the failing request (measured from the on-disk session transcript; all 779 lines parse as valid JSON, so the local file is intact):

Image tool-results accumulated in the session: 63. Growth is cumulative — images stay in context and are re-sent on every subsequent turn:

after image  1:  context  0.8 MB
after image 20:  context  5.5 MB
after image 40:  context 12.0 MB
after image 60:  context 22.5 MB

Why this looks like a size problem rather than a transient outage:

• The 22:19 failure and the 22:26 retry carried an identical payload → both failed.
• After auto-compaction drastically reduced the payload, the very next retry succeeded.
• The only variable that changed was payload size.

Steps to reproduce the issue

1. Start a session and read/attach images repeatedly (e.g. screenshots for transcription), so image tool-results accumulate in context.
2. Keep going until the serialized conversation reaches roughly 20 MB+ (63 image reads in this case).
3. From that point, requests fail with 502, and continue does not recover the turn.
4. Run /compact (or wait for auto-compaction) — the next request succeeds.

Command Code Version

1.74.1

Operating System

Windows

Terminal/IDE

Command Code desktop app (Electron)

Shell

PowerShell

Additional context

• Model: deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash
• Entrypoint: interactive
• Host: Windows 11 Pro, Build 26200, ASUS TUF Gaming A15; Node v24.16.0
• Session file: available on request. I'd rather not attach it publicly since it contains personal study material — but the measurements above were all taken from it, and the Trace IDs should let you pull the requests.
• Suggested improvements:
  1. Return a clearer error when the request body exceeds the gateway limit (e.g. 413 + "run /compact") instead of a mid-stream 502 that a retry cannot fix.
  2. Consider ageing out or replacing already-consumed image tool-results with a lightweight text placeholder, since each image is re-sent on every subsequent turn.
  3. Consider warning the user when the serialized request crosses a size threshold, so they can compact proactively.

(Trace IDs are included for debugging — noted in case they allow looking up the associated request content.)