Repository navigation
Incorrect translation of the phrase "non-whitespace" #141
Description
MDN-URL
https://developer.mozilla.org/de/docs/Web/CSS/:-moz-first-node
Um welchen spezifischen Abschnitt oder welche Überschrift geht es bei diesem Problem?
Einleitung
Welche Informationen waren falsch, unhilfreich oder unvollständig?
The english sentence "It differs from :first-child because it does not match a first-child element with (non-whitespace) text before it." has been translated to "Sie unterscheidet sich von :first-child, da sie kein erstes Kindelement erfasst, dem (nicht-weißer) Text vorausgeht."
Was hast du erwartet zu sehen?
I would have expected that english phrase "non-whitespace" out of the sentence "It differs from :first-child because it does not match a first-child element with (non-whitespace) text before it." would been translated to e.g. "exklusive Leerzeichen", "außer Leerzeichen" or "exklusive Leerzeichen" or something similar, resulting in "Sie unterscheidet sich von :first-child, da sie kein erstes Kindelement erfasst, dem Text (außer Leerzeichen) vorausgeht."
Hast du irgendwelche unterstützenden Links, Referenzen oder Zitate?
No response
Hast du noch etwas, das du teilen möchtest?
No response
MDN-Metadaten
Page report details
- Folder:
de/web/css/_colon_-moz-first-node - MDN URL: https://developer.mozilla.org/de/docs/Web/CSS/:-moz-first-node
- GitHub URL: https://github.com/mdn/translated-content-de/blob/main/files/de/web/css/_colon_-moz-first-node/index.md
- Last commit: 0eedbde
- Document last modified: 2025-10-25T00:28:10.000Z
Activity
caugner commentedon Nov 19, 2025
Meanwhile, the translation improved somewhat:
I'm not sure "Leerzeichen" is ideal, because it's ambiguous (can mean space or whitespace), so an alternative might be to just use the English word ("Whitespace") for clarity. Obviously, the glossary entry for Whitespace should mention the original term as well, but the translation prompt has not been optimized for specific page types, such as glossary pages, and it does not use a translation glossary.
mfranzke commentedon Dec 15, 2025
@caugner thanks a lot for bringing this up. I needed to look up the exact technical terms, and mainly found the following two sources, that brought some more clarity:
"Leerraumzeichen" seemed to be a good translation in the first place, but still only seem to refer to spaces (which to my understanding we'd like to avoid as we want to provide a reference to "whitespace" instead of "space", if I'm not mistaken). The best effort might be "Leerraum" according to the Wikipedia entry.
What about providing both words, "Leerraum" and "Whitespace" in these brackets, is this something you do in MDN for clarity and even also providing a technical term in the translated language?
Elsewhere I'm perfectly fine with only mentioning "Whitespace" as well; I was mainly confused by the initial translation, even though that I now understand it's background better after doing some further research.